Skills Product & Business Assessing Manuscript Fit for JBV

Assessing Manuscript Fit for JBV

v20260724
journal-of-business-venturing
This guide helps researchers determine if their manuscript is suitable for high-tier entrepreneurship journals like the Journal of Business Venturing (JBV). It provides specific criteria covering theoretical contribution, the centrality of the entrepreneurial process, methodological rigor (e.g., addressing selection bias), and adherence to journal house style, helping authors re-frame their work before submission.
Get Skill
498 downloads
Overview

Journal of Business Venturing (journal-of-business-venturing)

Journal positioning

Journal of Business Venturing (JBV), published by Elsevier, is one of the two flagship entrepreneurship journals and the premier outlet for research on the entrepreneurial process — new venture creation, opportunity identification and evaluation, and the behaviors and cognition of entrepreneurs. It rewards work that makes a clear contribution to entrepreneurship theory backed by rigorous empirics (or, less often, strong conceptual development). JBV is distinctively focused on the act and process of venturing, not generic small-business management or a strategy paper set among startups. The audience is entrepreneurship scholars, so the contribution must be entrepreneurship-central and theoretically grounded.

This skill is a fit / venue-selection / re-framing tool. It does not replace the journal's current official submission guidelines. Before submitting, re-check the live author instructions on the Elsevier / JBV site and the submission system.

When to trigger

  • The author names JBV (or the entrepreneurship flagship tier) as the venue.
  • A paper studies the entrepreneurial process — opportunity identification, venture creation, entrepreneurial cognition/behavior, founding teams, or new-venture growth.
  • A management/strategy paper set in startups needs re-framing around an entrepreneurship-theory contribution.
  • The author needs JBV's desk-reject risks and a credible entrepreneurship-theory-and-practice / strategic-management-journal / academy-of-management-journal alternative list.

Scope & topic fit

  • Opportunity identification, evaluation, and exploitation; the venture-creation process; effectuation and entrepreneurial decision-making.
  • Entrepreneurial cognition, behavior, motivation, and identity; founders and founding teams.
  • New venture emergence, growth, financing (angels, VC at the venture level), and exit.
  • Entrepreneurship across contexts (corporate, social, technology, international) when the entrepreneurial process is central.

Method & evidence bar

  • The contribution must advance entrepreneurship theory and turn on the entrepreneurial process, not a generic management effect observed in startups.
  • Empirical rigor is high — sound design, identification or careful inference, construct validity, and treatment of the selection and survivorship problems endemic to venture data.
  • Process and longitudinal designs are valued; cross-sectional survey work must address common-method bias and causality.
  • Conceptual papers must be genuinely novel and rigorously argued.

Structure & house style

  • The front end frames an entrepreneurship-theory problem about the venturing process and develops hypotheses or a grounded model with explicit logic.
  • A strong JBV paper states its contribution to entrepreneurship theory and bounds its conditions.
  • Methods address venture-data hazards (selection, survival, small/skewed samples); exhibits make the process legible.
  • House style rewards clear, theory-forward writing focused on the entrepreneurial phenomenon.

Official-submission checklist

  • Before giving submission-ready advice, read ../../resources/source-basis.md and ../../resources/official-source-map.md; start from the official source anchors for this journal family, then cite the current journal-specific page you checked.
  • Search the live site for "Journal of Business Venturing submission guidelines / Elsevier guide for authors" and follow the current version.
  • Re-check word/length limits, abstract format, anonymization for double-blind review, reference style, and data/code availability expectations.
  • Re-check current open-science, data-availability, and AI-use disclosure policies, and any article-type rules.
  • If the live official instructions conflict with this skill, the official instructions win.

Pre-submission self-check

  • One sentence stating the contribution to entrepreneurship theory — and confirming the entrepreneurial process is central.
  • Methods address selection, survivorship, and the hazards of venture data.
  • Hypotheses (or the inductive model) follow from explicit theoretical logic.
  • The paper is entrepreneurship-central, not a strategy/OB paper set among startups.
  • Framing, references, and anonymization match the current JBV guide.

Common desk-reject triggers

  • A generic strategy/OB study set in startups with no entrepreneurship-theory contribution.
  • Venture data analyzed without addressing selection/survivorship bias.
  • A descriptive small-business study with no theoretical contribution.
  • Cross-sectional survey with unaddressed common-method bias and weak causal logic.

Re-routing decision

  • Theory-driven entrepreneurship across diverse methods, including more conceptual work → entrepreneurship-theory-and-practice.
  • Entrepreneurship with a firm-strategy/performance core → strategic-management-journal; theory-driven management empirics → academy-of-management-journal.
  • Pure entrepreneurship theory, no data → academy-of-management-review; review of the entrepreneurship stream → academy-of-management-annals.
  • Org theory of new organizations → organization-science; broad management empirics → journal-of-management-en; international new ventures → journal-of-international-business-studies; innovation-driven venturing → research-policy.

Output format

[Fit] High / Medium / Low (one-line reason)
[Target] Journal of Business Venturing
[Topic tags] <2–3 closest topics>
[Method/evidence] <is the entrepreneurship-theory contribution + rigor at JBV's bar?>
[Top risk] <the single most likely reason for rejection>
[Official items to re-check] <submission system / length / references / data-code / article type>
[Re-route suggestion] <if not a fit, a better-matched venue>
Info
Name journal-of-business-venturing
Version v20260724
Size 6.09KB
Updated At 2026-07-28
Language