Because Organization Science is methodologically eclectic, "rigor" looks different by method. Report the standard that fits, transparently.
The venue holds that causal inference is valued but "not necessary and often impossible." Where clean identification is unavailable, support inference with mechanism evidence, theoretical logic, institutional knowledge, triangulation, and falsification/placebo logic, and rule out alternatives empirically where possible. Do not overclaim causality; do not abandon a credible mechanism for want of an instrument.
Provide enough detail and references that others could replicate the work. Under the 2025 data and
methods transparency policy, authors should be ready to share statistical code upon editor request
during review, and accepted quantitative papers must publicly share data/code unless a documented
exception and alternative transparency plan applies. Keep clean, regenerable scripts regardless of
whether the underlying data can be public.
Run the battery, don't just enumerate it. Full map:execution-with-mcp. Org Science spans field studies, experiments, and computational/qualitative work; the chain below is for its empirical/causal lane — simulation and qualitative work are outside it.
romano_wolf (step-down FWER) orbenjamini_hochberg — report the adjusted threshold.
oster_delta / sensemakr.wild_cluster_bootstrap (few clusters), twoway_cluster / conley;multilevel data → cluster at the right level.
audit_result(result_id) lists the missing checks and theexact suggest_function for each.
etable / did_summary_to_latex from the handle — no retyped numbers.Keep the decisive checks in the body and the exhaustive battery in the appendix. See the
executed chain in the JF execution walkthrough.
Use this as a second-pass capability check. First lock a level map, a mechanism paragraph, and the cover-letter contribution statement; then test whether the manuscript addresses interdisciplinary organization reviewers who ask whether the mechanism travels across levels of analysis.
claim / evidence / blocker / next edit rows so the next pass can patch the manuscript directly.resources/official-source-map.md forupload-week rules and name the one live-check item that could change the recommendation.
【Method】qualitative / multilevel / panel-EH / experiment / simulation / formal
【Rigor evidence】trustworthiness (data structure, audit trail) OR estimator + SE clustering OR sensitivity/seeds OR proofs
【Inference】identification? if not — mechanism + design logic + falsification; alternatives ruled out
【Replicability】detail/scripts ready; data/code sharing or exception plan ready
【Next step】orgsci-contribution-framing