Skill UI

This guide outlines the rigorous, multi-step process for authors revising a mathematical or scientific manuscript following a detailed referee report. It emphasizes the critical rule: always fix mathematical gaps and errors in the text first, and only then draft a structured, point-by-point reply that is respectful, precise, and mathematically grounded.

This guide details the strategic process for writing a technical rebuttal (e.g., for SIGGRAPH), focusing on correcting factual errors and answering specific reviewer questions under strict constraints (e.g., 1000 words, text-only). It also outlines the required steps for the second-stage revision after conditional acceptance, ensuring authors address all committee requirements.