Run this audit before uploading to the FSE HotCRP site. FSE research papers are published as
journal articles in PACMSE (Proceedings of the ACM on Software Engineering), so the
submission is judged like a journal manuscript that also earns a conference slot. Every number
below was read from the FSE 2026/2027 research-papers calls on 2026-07-09 via search renderings
of the conf.researchr.org URLs (see resources/official-source-map.md); treat them as a
one-cycle snapshot and reopen the live call first.
FSE separates paper registration from paper submission, and both are AoE:
Register with the real title and abstract, not a placeholder — the abstract drives reviewer bidding, and a registered abstract that diverges from the final paper quietly worsens your PC match.
FSE runs heavy double-anonymous review: anonymity is preserved through all reviewing and discussion, and even a later Major Revision response letter must stay anonymous. Because SE papers lean on tools, repositories, and mined data, the leak surface is wide:
# Mechanical pass on the submission PDF and any anonymized artifact archive
pdfinfo paper.pdf | grep -Ei 'author|creator|producer'
pdftotext paper.pdf - | grep -nEi 'github\.com/[a-z0-9-]+|gitlab|zenodo\.org/record|acknowledg|grant' | head
unzip -l artifact.zip | grep -Ei '\.git/|\.DS_Store|/home/|/Users/' | head
grep -rni 'university\|@[a-z0-9.]*\.edu\|our (tool|group|lab)' artifact/ --include='*.md' | head
The SE-specific leaks: a tool named after your lab, a screenshot showing a username, a data- availability link pointing at a personal GitHub, commit metadata inside a zipped repository, and issue-tracker URLs in the evaluation. Re-host artifacts behind an anonymizing service before upload.
FSE expects sharing by default under an open-science policy. Concretely for the submission:
| Finding at audit time | Severity | Real fix |
|---|---|---|
| Main text over the page budget | Desk-reject-grade | Cut or move to the artifact; reference pages do not absorb body text |
| Template altered (margins, shrunk font) | Named desk-reject ground | Recompile clean, recover space editorially |
| Identity leak in PDF, artifact, or tool name | Anonymity violation | Re-anonymize and re-host; scrub PDF metadata |
| Abstract/paper not registered by the earlier date | No submission slot exists | Nothing fixes this post-AoE — calendar it now |
| No availability statement, no artifact | Scored against the paper | Add the statement + an anonymized package |
| Same study under review elsewhere | Dual-submission exposure | Withdraw one venue; verify the current concurrent-submission wording |
[FSE submission status] ready / blocked / needs work
[Registration] title/abstract/authors/conflicts locked by the earlier deadline? yes/no
[Format] pages used (body/refs), ACM template compliance
[Anonymity] clean / leaks: <where>
[Open science] artifact link present? Data Availability statement present?
[Fix queue] <ordered, with owners and dates before the AoE cutoff>