技能 数据科学 ICDT会议论文投稿审核指南

ICDT会议论文投稿审核指南

v20260724
icdt-submission
这是一份为作者准备国际数据库理论会议(ICDT)论文的全面审核指南。内容涵盖选择正确的投稿周期、遵守摘要和论文的两步截止日期、符合LIPIcs格式规范(不含参考文献的页数限制),以及确保提供完整、可验证的证明和严格的匿名化要求。建议在上传至Microsoft CMT前使用本指南进行自查。
获取技能
435 次下载
概览

ICDT Submission

Run this audit before uploading to Microsoft CMT for the International Conference on Database Theory. ICDT is a pure database-theory venue: reviewers read for a precise theorem, a correct proof, and a genuine advance in the foundations of data management, and they publish the result open access in LIPIcs (Schloss Dagstuhl). Every number below was read on 2026-07-09 from the ICDT 2026/2027 calls at databasetheory.org via search renderings (see resources/official-source-map.md); treat them as a one-cycle snapshot and reopen the live call first.

Pick the right cycle first

ICDT runs two submission cycles per year, and choosing the cycle is the first decision, not a detail:

  • Cycle 1 closes in the (northern) spring and offers a revision option — a first decision can be Accept, Revise-and-resubmit, or Reject.
  • Cycle 2 closes in the (northern) autumn; a paper rejected in Cycle 1 may not be resubmitted to Cycle 2 unless the reviewers explicitly invited it. Do not treat the two cycles as a free second attempt.

For ICDT 2027 (Lille), Cycle 1 papers were due 10 March 2026 and Cycle 2 papers 10 September 2026 (AoE); confirm the live dates. If your proof might still move, the earlier cycle's revision round is worth more than a later raw submission.

The two-step deadline

Each cycle separates an abstract deadline from the paper deadline, both AoE and about a week apart (ICDT 2027 Cycle 1: abstracts 3 March 2026, papers 10 March 2026):

  • Register the abstract with the real title and abstract — it drives PC bidding and conflict handling. A placeholder abstract worsens your reviewer match.
  • Miss the abstract deadline and CMT will not accept the PDF later.

Format and page budget

  • lipics-v2021 LIPIcs document class, unmodified. This is the Dagstuhl LaTeX style, not acmart and not IEEEtran — do not carry a PODS/SIGMOD acmart habit across.
  • At most 15 pages excluding references. References do not count against the 15; nothing else escapes it except the appendix below.
  • A clearly marked appendix is allowed but read at the PC's discretion. The main 15 pages must contain everything needed to assess the contribution; the appendix holds the full proofs a referee may check. Online/external appendices are not allowed — everything reviewed lives in the single submitted PDF.

Complete proofs and the full version

ICDT expects complete, checkable proofs. A theorem stated without a proof a referee can verify is the classic desk-level weakness at a theory venue:

  • Put proof sketches and the main argument in the body; put the full details in the marked appendix so the paper is self-contained within one PDF.
  • Maintain a full version (typically on arXiv) that will carry the complete proofs after review; reference it in the camera-ready, not in an anonymized submission if the link deanonymizes you.

Anonymous-submission sweep (since 2024)

ICDT regular papers are anonymous: the PDF must not reveal authorship.

# Mechanical pass on the submission PDF
pdfinfo paper.pdf | grep -Ei 'author|creator|producer'
pdftotext paper.pdf - | grep -nEi 'acknowledg|grant|funded by|our (previous|earlier) (work|paper)|\bwe .* in \[[0-9]+\]' | head
  • Remove author names, affiliations, and acknowledgments to funding sources and collaborators.
  • Cite your own prior work in the third person ("Building on the construction of [17]…"), not "our earlier paper [17]."
  • If you post a full version, do not let an arXiv link or an identifying system name reintroduce your identity into the anonymous PDF.
  • Note the exception: the Database Theory in Action short-paper track is not anonymous — the anonymity rule is for the regular research track.

Desk-risk triage

Finding at audit time Severity Real fix
Body over 15 pages (excl. refs) Format-reject-grade Move detail to the marked appendix; tighten the body — refs do not absorb it
Class altered (margins, font, \vspace hacks) Named format ground Recompile clean lipics-v2021; recover space by editing, not by shrinking
A theorem with no verifiable proof anywhere in the PDF Fatal at a theory venue Add the full proof to the appendix before upload
Author identity leaks (names, acks, "our tool") Anonymity violation Re-anonymize; scrub PDF metadata; neutralize self-citations
Abstract not registered by the earlier deadline No paper slot exists Nothing fixes this post-AoE — calendar it now
Resubmitting a Cycle-1 reject into Cycle 2 uninvited Against the cross-cycle rule Do not; only resubmit if reviewers invited it
Same result under review at PODS/a journal Concurrent-submission exposure Withdraw one; check the current dual-submission wording

Final-week order of operations

  1. Freeze the theorem statements early; the exposition can churn, the results cannot.
  2. Register the abstract in the correct cycle before the earlier deadline.
  3. Confirm every claimed theorem has a complete proof in the body or the marked appendix.
  4. Run the anonymity sweep on the final PDF, including self-citation phrasing.
  5. Fill every CMT field — subject areas that match your result, conflicts for each coauthor's institution and recent collaborators — a day early.
  6. Re-download the uploaded PDF and read it cold to confirm it is the file you meant.

Reverify each cycle

  • The cycle dates, which cycle you are targeting, and the revision-window length.
  • The page limit and the required LIPIcs class revision.
  • The anonymous-submission wording and any generative-AI disclosure rule (待核实).
  • Whether the Database Theory in Action track runs and its separate rules.

Output format

[ICDT submission status] ready / blocked / needs work
[Cycle] 1 (revision-eligible) / 2 (no uninvited carry), abstract+paper registered? yes/no
[Format] pages used (body/refs), lipics-v2021 compliance, appendix marked?
[Proofs] every theorem has a checkable proof in-PDF? yes/no
[Anonymity] clean / leaks: <where>
[Fix queue] <ordered, with dates before the AoE cutoff>
信息
Category 数据科学
Name icdt-submission
版本 v20260724
大小 6.59KB
更新时间 2026-07-28
语言