This is a theory-first journal. Mathematical Finance explicitly states that **numerical
experiments are welcome only when accompanied by a rigorous analysis** supporting the
theoretical developments, and that **routine application of computational methods to financial
data will not be considered**. So "data analysis" here is not empirical estimation — it is
numerical work that illustrates or stress-tests a theorem. This skill is deliberately lighter
than its empirical-journal counterpart.
theorem, proposition, or rate (e.g., "Monte Carlo error decays at the proven $O(n^{-1/2})$
rate", "the free boundary matches the smooth-fit characterization").
finite-difference/finite-element), step sizes, number of paths, variance reduction,
truncation of the domain — enough that the experiment is reproducible.
empirical rate against it; show convergence as the grid refines.
illustration speaks to the modelling problem.
Do not let a numerical section grow into a stand-alone empirical study.
mathfin-replication-and-data-policy).
| Result being illustrated | Natural scheme | What the exhibit must report |
|---|---|---|
| Strong/weak SDE convergence rate | Euler–Maruyama or Milstein with halving steps | log–log error slope against the proven order |
| BSDE well-posedness or rate | Backward Euler / least-squares Monte Carlo / deep BSDE solver | terminal error and driver residual across grids |
| Optimal stopping / free boundary | Binomial tree or PDE variational-inequality solver | boundary location against the smooth-fit characterization |
| Rough-volatility approximation | Hybrid scheme for fractional kernels; Markovian lift | implied-vol skew slope against the proven power law |
| Duality gap = 0 | Primal candidate and dual bound computed independently | gap shrinking as the discretization refines |
| Mean-field limit | N-player simulation vs. McKean–Vlasov solver | distance to the limit decaying in N at the stated rate |
Suppose Theorem 3.2 proves that a Markovian multi-factor approximation of a rough volatility
model converges at a rate governed by the Hurst parameter H. The journal-appropriate exhibit:
simulate both models with the same Brownian increments, plot the implied-volatility error
against the number of factors on log axes, draw the theoretical slope as a reference line, and
caption with the scheme, step size, path count, seed, and the theorem number. What would NOT
fit: calibrating the approximation to index-option data and reporting fit quality — that turns
an illustration into the empirical study the journal screens out.
proven one.
closed forms before the general runs are trusted.
【Experiment】what it illustrates (which theorem/rate)
【Method】scheme + step/paths + variance reduction
【Error reported】empirical vs. theoretical rate/bound
【Parameters】financial values used
【Reproducibility】seeds + versions + code location
【Next step】mathfin-tables-figures